Singing From The Same Old Hymn Sheet

Why, isn’t that UK comedy stalwart Mark Heap in the opening scene of new ABC comedy A Moody Christmas? Why yes it is. Will we ever see him again? Probably not. Still, having him in the background of one scene is better than nothing at all, and he does provide a signpost to the path that this particular ABC take on UK-style “family” comedy will be heading down: actors doing comedy rather than stand-up comedians doing acting.

Unfortunately, as those of you with eyes to see are already painfully aware, Australia is not home to a vast array of first-rate comedy actors. So what quickly develops here is a sitcom – there’s a situation (Christmas), there’s comedy (of a sort), it’s a sitcom – where we get a fun bunch of traditional comedy character who aren’t really given much of a spark by the cast. We’re not saying they’re bad actors or anything; they’re just not hilarious actors, and when you’re playing types like “the sleazy uncle”, “the boring uncle”, “the smarmy go-getter cousin” and “the dodgy small businessman brother (remember the brother Adam Scott played in the movie Step Brothers? He’s basically that guy)”, it really really helps if you can bring something to the party.

A party is what the show is about, by the way: it’s Christmas, and photographer Dan Moody (Ian Meadows) is back from the UK without his girlfriend, who dumped him at the airport in front of Mark Heap. Time for a family Christmas! Yes, it’s a bunch of old fights re-heated, petty rivalries, annoying relatives crapping on, bad food, hot weather, and so on. We’ve all been there, and the show’s big strength is that it taps into a situation that’s pretty much universal. Well, is it until the bit where they dress up as Santa to break into a garage to steal back a ride-on mower.

Much as writing is usually the weak link in Australian drama – and this is basically a mild drama with jokes, rather than an US-style joke-onslaught sitcom – here the writing is actually pretty good. The characters, while generic, are well observed, the bitchy family relationships feel spot-on, and the first episode ticks along pretty well as a whole. There’s nothing at all stand-out here, but it doesn’t fall in a heap either. Thumbs up there to Phil Lloyd and Trent O’Donnell, of Review with Myles Barlow fame.

Alarm bells start a-ringing when it turns out that, years ago when he was a cadet, Dan took a famous photo where a woman died in a fire – seems public opinion (and the opinion of much of his family) is that trying to save her probably would have been a better option than taking a photo. But Cora (Jane Harber) gives him the “OMG sympathy” look and biff bam pow we’re in the blandly predictable world of dramedy yet again. It’s a throw away moment, sure, but it’s a forced one and this just hasn’t been funny enough – or delved anywhere near deeply into any of its characters – to be trying to get away with it so early in the piece.

Let’s be clear here: we watch comedies to laugh. We don’t watch comedies for romantic relationships. So the seemingly endless cutaways to Cora looking on sympathetically (or horrified) as the Moody family get on Dan’s nerves and/or treat him like crap add very little to proceedings as far as we’re concerned. Your milage may vary, but c’mon: “will-they-or-won’t-they” is fine as a minor subplot in a serial drama or a long-running comedy, but in a six-part half hour comedy series it really feels like they aren’t confident that the comedy alone will keep people watching. Which, to be fair, is probably fair enough.

This may pick up in future weeks, but the premise – we check back in with the Moody’s every Christmas –  doesn’t give us a lot of hope there. It’s a good premise, but it really needs much stronger characters to work if it’s going to keep approaching things realistically. Christmas gatherings are a time when people fall into a rut, playing a role within their family, and from the first episode none of the one-note characters (the sister: I’m pregnant! Next week: we have to have sex so I can get pregnant!) or the roles they play are going to sustain six weeks of comedy unless they seriously go off the rails.

In the end this is more “quality” than “funny”. The laugh-out-loud moments are pretty much non-existent but if The (UK) Office has taught us anything it’s that if you can’t get laughs, moments of recognition are almost as good. Sure, mostly what you’re going to recognise here is a local take on one of those bland “family” UK sitcoms the ABC are always importing to zero interest from the viewing public. Or maybe just another Australian sitcom that isn’t really very funny. But who watches comedy for the laughs these days?

 

Similar Posts
Spicks and Specks – the 12″ Mega Mix
Spicks and Specks is back! Again. And it’s like it never went away. Again. There was nothing particularly broke about...
Josh’s Gonna Josh
Everything’s Gonna Be Okay returned to Stan last week, and we all know what that means: loads of articles scattered...
Don’t Get All Dramatic
Wakefield is a new ABC series from Jungle Entertainment, the production company responsible for, amongst other things, Squinters, Sando, The...

2 Comments

  • The Doogster says:

    I actually thought this was far better than ABC sitcoms of recent years, which means it’s better than crap like Laid, Outland and The Librarians. So the bar has not been set very high.

    What AMC did right was get the characters up and running quickly. None of the usual “hey, we’ll establish the characters by the end of the first series”. It’s refreshing to see an opening scene that embraced brevity – in fact, all of the scenes were of the right length for comedy, with no treading water. Also, the dialog was quite sharp and snappy (but not particularly witty), which again is a change from the usual crap where there is lots of empty space (I’m looking at you, Librarians). Basically, there is lots of “stuff” in AMC, which creates the opportunity for comedy, assuming the writers can rise to the occasion.

    Another positive was the presence of characters who quickly inject humour into the proceedings, which for me is the defining feature of good comedy. There is a good mix of characters, even if they are somewhat one-dimensional. When things are flagging, the writers know how to spice things up with a well-timed interjection.

    On the downside, it’s light on laughs. The scenarios they get themselves into don’t have a great deal of depth. Their problems and aspirations seem quite shallow, which does not generate great humour.

    After the disappointment of The Strange Calls, I might just give this series a go. If so, it will be the first Australian TV comedy series I’ve watched from start to finish since Summer Heights High. The challenge is on…

  • Andrew says:

    I watched this on iView last night and I didn’t think it was that bad apart from the bit about stealing the lawn mower – that part was stupid. But for me the episode flew by pretty quickly. Not really a lot of LOL moments but certainly some chuckles and like you say some moments of recognition which we could all relate to.

    Ian Meadows I think is perfect in his role as Dan and the rest of the cast also work well.
    And nice to see Robina Beard as grandma, although maybe I’m the only one old enough to remember her from many years ago doing those Palmolive dishwashing liquid ads.

    Having not been thrilled by previous ABC comedies like Laid, Outland and Angry Boys, A Moody Christmas is I think a welcome return to form and I look forward to episode two.