Vale Rosehaven series 2

Rosehaven‘s an unusual one in today’s TV landscape. If you imagine a scale with drama at one end, comedy at the other, and dramedy in the middle, Rosehaven‘s somewhere between dramedy and comedy; never quite funny enough to satisfy the likes of us, but not quite mirthless enough to be the sort of thing that people who don’t like comedy might enjoy.

Rosehaven

In fact, the bits which are funny in Rosehaven are the sort of humour that people who find comedy annoying, hate about comedy. Stuff like when Emma and Daniel have childish arguments, or engage in tit-for-tat, or dare each other to do stupid things. A lot of this stuff is really funny – and Celia Pacquola and Luke McGregor play it perfectly. But it’s too much like comedy for a dramedy fan.

Except, then there’s a scene where Daniel’s mum says something dry which doesn’t quite work because Kris McQuade plays it too scary, or a scene involving a local eccentric and the actor doesn’t quite time the line right – or their lines aren’t that good in the first place – and that’s where Rosehaven falls into a bit of slump.

What we’re saying here is: if this were The Emma and Daniel (or Celia and Luke) Show it’d probably be a lot funnier. It might be incredibly exhausting too, but we’d be laughing more.

But what do we know? The New York Times liked it. It described it as…

Affable and human

…which it definitely is. Rosehaven the affable: the kind of show you’d be happy to have in your home again because it’s a bit funny, but not so funny that you’d ruin the couch laughing.

Similar Posts
Today Tonightly
We’ve waited a while before passing judgement on Tonightly, ABC Comedy’s new tonight show, because unlike pretty much every Australian...
There will be Fresh Blood
Recently, there was an exciting announcement. The ABC said it was creating a new channel dedicated entirely to comedy, called...
Vale Aaron Chen Tonight
So, Aaron Chen Tonight ended last week. Tucked away on late night ABC2, it was a show that was easily missed, which...

2 Comments

  • sven says:

    Yeah, and cheering on a real estate agent trying to sell houses, and a character who falls into jobs but complains because she can’t be with her friend aint too bright either… the bit where a new homebuyer paid an extra 35k on a house so Luke could feel good about himself would have gone down a riot in certain sectors of the community too.
    Resembles too many of the ‘fresh blood’ efforts too. Not really tapping into the zeitgeist these fresh comedians.

  • […] cheat on essays and mess around. It’s kind of a more wild version of Emma and Daniel in Rosehaven – and a similar sense of humour. This is one of four Fresh Blood projects to be […]

Leave a Reply


Name (required)

Email (required)

Website