Live From The End Of Days

Nobody seriously expected anything startlingly original from Nine’s first proper stab at prime time “all-new” comedy in almost a decade. Once the cast details for Live From Planet Earth eaked out – name after name from Comedy inc is never a good sign – expectations for anything fresher than the contents of Elvis’ colon evaporated. But it’s fair to say nobody expected the show they’d end up ripping off would be Let Loose Live.

In case you were one of the billions of people who missed Let Loose Live during its two week run on Seven back in 2005, it too was a live-to-air sketch show with a name host (only there, they had a different host each week). And while the idea of live sketches clearly has some hold over the fossils of all ages running commercial television in this country, it didn’t take long to realise that even in the 21st century “live sketches” are basically two people crapping onto each other without a decent punchline in sight. Maybe if you’re Shaun Micallef and Stephen Curry reviving Peter Cook and Dudley Moore sketches you can make it work: if you can’t bring that level of quality to the table, maybe it’s time to move into a world where Mr Show happened 15 years ago.

Oh, that’s right: Let Loose Live went for TWO WEEKS. Axed after its second outing. Which just maybe makes it a model to avoid when you’re hoping for a success. But don’t worry, Nine didn’t just rip off Let Loose Live; remember the original Hamish & Andy Show on Seven? Just like Live From Planet Earth, it featured (a) name-brand host(s), and teamed them up with a crack team of sketch comedy veterans. It too lasted two big weeks. Maybe because the “crack comedy veterans” were mostly tired sketch show hacks no-one found funny the first time.

And speaking of the cast of Live From Planet Earth, plucked fresh from the string of failed sketch shows that have littered the Australian television landscape throughout the first decade of this century, what more can we say? On the one hand, having Elton hosting a show full of young fresh faces would have made him look like an old fart, and clearly Nine wanted to go with safe hands for the live sketches. On the other hand, it’s a cast that’s been proven unfunny time and time and time again. And now, again.

On the plus side, Elton himself… ok, he made a lot of jokes about female genitalia. And when it wasn’t making jokes about poo and boobs, the show as a whole wasn’t afraid to stick it to those “bogans” we’ve been hearing so much about either. If you were wondering how “live comedy’ was going to fit in with Nine’s Footy Show corporate culture, your questions were answered by the second riff on pregnant teens. We get it, poor people are funny! You’ve got to look down on someone, amiright?

Anyway, back to the pluses. Elton himself was moderately polished, even if his material was largely playing to the cheap seats. That’s nowhere near enough to save a show like this – Hamish & Andy’s show on Seven suffered the same fate, dragged down by shit sketch after shit sketch – but it does suggest that if they ditched, say, 95% of the live comedy Elton might be able to survive on his “fuck you, I’m with AAMI” material. At least Arj Barker as the only other stand-up was funny, even if he was clearly giving old material (about last year’s Icelandic volcano) one last airing before retiring it for good.

Perhaps the saddest thing about tonight’s episode was the way Elton kept telling us that we’d be seeing more next week from each character and live sitcom-

[which was also largely arse but at least was cartoony enough to break up the otherwise uniform vibe of the show – say what you like about old-style sketch shows like Fast Forward or The Late Show, but they knew enough to break up the rhythm of the sketches. Some short, some long, some live in-studio, some filmed outside. This was all one-note – even the celebrity interview with Ruby Rose – making it increasingly difficult for any of the material to break through and get a laugh as it went along.]

– even though anyone with even a passing interest in Australian comedy (especially on commercial networks) knows that “next week” is never a sure (or even likely) thing. Chances are the ratings figures will be muddied by having Top Gear run a full 15 minutes late beforehand, which should give Nine enough cover to bring Live From Planet Earth back next week despite the caning it took on twitter.

As for the week after that? Maybe if a live sketch comedy show had lasted more than two weeks on Australian commercial television at any stage during the last decade, we’d be more confident…

Similar Posts
Vale Talkin’ ’bout Your Generation 2018
And so Talkin’ ’bout Your Generation 2018 died the way it lived: as a show that was probably too good...
Leaving a Mark
Twenty-four hours ago, Australian comedy was rocked to its very core: Mark Humphries 24 June at 20:49 · Tomorrow is...
Tonightly 2.0 and the elephant in the room
Tonightly, the ABC Comedy nightly satire show that’s divided opinion on this blog and in the world of the mainstream...

4 Comments

  • Why ben says:

    Fairly accurate review. A lot less scathing than most of the comments tearing ot a new arsehole on twitter. Obe thing, hamish and Andy weren’t name brand comedians in 2004, they’d been plucked off channel 31 and had barely appeared on fox. And chris Lillee was in that cast. The let loose live comparison is far more apt.

  • 13 schoolyards says:

    Good point. To be clear, The H&A show had then unknowns H&A parachuted into a show where the sketch cast (yes, even Lilley) had freshly come from a proven failure (in this case Big Bite). Much like Live From Planet Earth, the result was a show that often felt roughly stitched together, which isn’t a feel that brings the laughs.

    Not to mention that seeing a bunch of faces audiences had already rejected / ignored once is hardly the way to bring the excitement. Paul McCarthy? Again?

  • Kenny says:

    While Ben Elton’s show was clearly awful, your story lacks any cred with such gaping errors in research. For a start, Hamish and Andy were NOT name hosts when they hosted their show on Seven – they were fresh from Channel 31 and had yet to go to Austereo. For a second, the show lasted six episodes, not two. And “name after name” from Comedy Inc? Two

  • 13 schoolyards says:

    Kenny, as the post above clarifies, the H&A reference was more in reference to the style of pre-packaged show they were parachuted in to host rather than their status as “names” at the time – though it was their names in the title, ironically or not.

    Your second point is wrong. Only two episodes of the Hamish & Andy Show aired at the time – the remaining four went unseen until the recent screening on Seven’s HD channel.

    And two names from Comedy Inc is “name after name”, isn’t it? To be fair, there was also one cast member from Let Loose Live. Which isn’t exactly an improvement.